Critics' Picks 172 Items

List Page Learn About Content Graphic

You're no longer following this brand

You'll no longer receive alerts for new arrivals and brand updates

Critics' Picks, null
All Filters
Gift Type
Gift Type
    Occasion
    Occasion
      Variety
      Variety
        Price
        Price
        Price $0 $300+
        Rating
        Rating
        Professional Rating Unrated 100 points
        Customer Rating Unrated 5.0 fantastic
        Ships Anytime
        Availability
        Shipping availability and out of stock options
        Standard (750ml)
        Fine Wine
        ABV
        ABV
        ABV 0% 18% +
        Reset
        Back to All Filters
        Filter & Sort
        172 Items
        Most Popular
        Search results for "" 172 Items
        • Teso la Monja Almirez 2022
          Toro, Spain Tempranillo
          • 95 Vinous
          • 93 Jeb
            Dunnuck
          • 93 Robert
            Parker
          • 92 Wine
            Spectator
          • 92 James
            Suckling
          3.5 Very Good (9)
            1
            Limit Reached
            Ships Mon, Apr 27
            Limit 0 per customer
            Sold in increments of 0
          • Tenuta di Capraia Chianti Classico Riserva 2019
            Chianti Classico, Chianti, Tuscany, Italy Sangiovese
            • 95 Wine
              Spectator
            • 93 Wilfred
              Wong
            • 92 James
              Suckling
            • 91 Vinous
            • 91 Jeb
              Dunnuck
            • 91 Decanter
            4.2 Very Good (192)
              1
              Limit Reached
              Ships Mon, Apr 27
              Limit 0 per customer
              Sold in increments of 0
            • Grand Napa Vineyards Master Red 2019
              Napa Valley, California Bordeaux Red Blends
              • 91 James
                Suckling
              • 90 Wine
                Spectator
              • 90 Wilfred
                Wong
              4.4 Very Good (195)
                1
                Limit Reached
                Ships Mon, Apr 27
                Limit 0 per customer
                Sold in increments of 0
              • La Rioja Alta Vina Alberdi Reserva Tinto 2020
                Rioja, Spain Tempranillo
                • 93 James
                  Suckling
                • 92 Wine
                  Enthusiast
                • 91 Wine
                  Spectator
                4.1 Very Good (77)
                  1
                  Limit Reached
                  Ships Mon, Apr 27
                  Limit 0 per customer
                  Sold in increments of 0
                • Bodega Garzon Uruguay Reserva Tannat 2023
                  Uruguay Tannat
                  • 91 Wine
                    Spectator
                  • 91 James
                    Suckling
                  • 91 Wine
                    Enthusiast
                  • 90 Jeb
                    Dunnuck
                  • 90 Vinous
                  3.5 Very Good (11)
                    1
                    Limit Reached
                    Ships Mon, Apr 27
                    Limit 0 per customer
                    Sold in increments of 0
                  • Tenuta di Capraia Chianti Classico Effe 55 Gran Selezione 2018
                    Chianti Classico, Chianti, Tuscany, Italy Sangiovese
                    • 95 Wine
                      Spectator
                    • 93 James
                      Suckling
                    • 93 Wilfred
                      Wong
                    • 92 Robert
                      Parker
                    • 92 Vinous
                    4.0 Very Good (175)
                    • Boutique
                    1
                    Limit Reached
                    Ships Mon, Apr 27
                    Limit 0 per customer
                    Sold in increments of 0
                  • Frescobaldi CastelGiocondo Brunello di Montalcino 2020
                    Montalcino, Tuscany, Italy Sangiovese
                    • 94 James
                      Suckling
                    • 93 Wine
                      Spectator
                    • 93 Decanter
                    • 92 Vinous
                    • 92 Jeb
                      Dunnuck
                    3.5 Very Good (5)
                      1
                      Limit Reached
                      Ships Mon, Apr 27
                      Limit 0 per customer
                      Sold in increments of 0
                    • Invivo X by Sarah Jessica Parker Pinot Noir 2022
                      Marlborough, New Zealand Pinot Noir
                      • 91 James
                        Suckling
                      • 91 Wine
                        Enthusiast
                      • 90 Wine
                        Spectator
                      3.0 Good (23)
                      • Green
                      • Screw Cap
                      1
                      Limit Reached
                      Ships Mon, Apr 27
                      Limit 0 per customer
                      Sold in increments of 0
                    • Marchesi Antinori Pian Delle Vigne Brunello di Montalcino 2020
                      Montalcino, Tuscany, Italy Sangiovese
                      • 94 Wine
                        Spectator
                      • 94 James
                        Suckling
                      • 93 Vinous
                      • 92 Jeb
                        Dunnuck
                        1
                        Limit Reached
                        Ships Mon, Apr 27
                        Limit 0 per customer
                        Sold in increments of 0
                      • Merry Edwards Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir 2021
                        Sonoma Coast, Sonoma County, California Pinot Noir
                        • 94 James
                          Suckling
                        • 93 Wine
                          Enthusiast
                        • 93 Wine
                          Spectator
                        • 93 Jeb
                          Dunnuck
                        • 90 Vinous
                          1
                          Limit Reached
                          Ships Mon, Apr 27
                          Limit 0 per customer
                          Sold in increments of 0
                        • Last call - only 5 left!
                          Flechas De Los Andes Gran Corte 2012
                          Uco Valley, Mendoza, Argentina Other Red Blends
                          • 93 James
                            Suckling
                          • 91 Wine
                            Enthusiast
                          • 91 Robert
                            Parker
                          • 90 Decanter
                            1
                            Limit Reached
                            Ships Mon, Apr 27
                            Limit 0 per customer
                            Sold in increments of 0
                          • Gaja Ca'Marcanda Magari 2023
                            Bolgheri, Tuscany, Italy Bordeaux Red Blends
                            • 95 Jeb
                              Dunnuck
                            • 94 Robert
                              Parker
                            • 92 James
                              Suckling
                            • 90 Wine
                              Spectator
                              1
                              Limit Reached
                              Ships Mon, Apr 27
                              Limit 0 per customer
                              Sold in increments of 0
                            • Mendel Unus 2021
                              Mendoza, Argentina Bordeaux Red Blends
                              • 94 Robert
                                Parker
                              • 93 James
                                Suckling
                              • 91 Wine
                                Enthusiast
                                1
                                Limit Reached
                                Ships Mon, Apr 27
                                Limit 0 per customer
                                Sold in increments of 0
                              • Lions Head Panthera Pinot Noir 2021
                                Sonoma Coast, Sonoma County, California Pinot Noir
                                • 95 Wine
                                  Enthusiast
                                • 93 James
                                  Suckling
                                • 92 Wine
                                  Spectator
                                3.5 Very Good (12)
                                  1
                                  Limit Reached
                                  Ships Mon, Apr 27
                                  Limit 0 per customer
                                  Sold in increments of 0
                                • Clos Henri Waimaunga Pinot Noir 2020
                                  Marlborough, New Zealand Pinot Noir
                                  • 95 Wilfred
                                    Wong
                                  • 94 Robert
                                    Parker
                                  • 94 Wine
                                    Enthusiast
                                  4.2 Very Good (53)
                                  • Green
                                  1
                                  Limit Reached
                                  Ships Mon, Apr 27
                                  Limit 0 per customer
                                  Sold in increments of 0
                                • Patz & Hall Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir 2021
                                  Sonoma Coast, Sonoma County, California Pinot Noir
                                  • 96 Decanter
                                  • 93 Wine
                                    Spectator
                                  • 90 Robert
                                    Parker
                                  3.9 Very Good (29)
                                    1
                                    Limit Reached
                                    Ships Mon, Apr 27
                                    Limit 0 per customer
                                    Sold in increments of 0
                                  • Zenato Amarone della Valpolicella Classico 2019
                                    Veneto, Italy Other Red Blends
                                    • 95 James
                                      Suckling
                                    • 93 Wine
                                      Spectator
                                    • 90 Wine
                                      Enthusiast
                                    4.2 Very Good (6)
                                      1
                                      Limit Reached
                                      Ships Mon, Apr 27
                                      Limit 0 per customer
                                      Sold in increments of 0
                                    • Villota Selvanevada Rioja 2022
                                      Rioja, Spain Tempranillo
                                      • 91 Wine
                                        Spectator
                                      • 91 James
                                        Suckling
                                      • 91 Jeb
                                        Dunnuck
                                      • 91 Vinous
                                      4.0 Very Good (11)
                                        1
                                        Limit Reached
                                        Ships Mon, Apr 27
                                        Limit 0 per customer
                                        Sold in increments of 0
                                      • Sandrone Barolo Le Vigne 2020
                                        Barolo, Piedmont, Italy Nebbiolo
                                        • 96 Wine
                                          Enthusiast
                                        • 96 James
                                          Suckling
                                        • 95 Wine
                                          Spectator
                                        • 95 Robert
                                          Parker
                                        • 94 Jeb
                                          Dunnuck
                                        • 94 Vinous
                                        • Collectible
                                        1
                                        Limit Reached
                                        Ships Mon, Apr 27
                                        Limit 0 per customer
                                        Sold in increments of 0
                                      • Banshee Sonoma County Pinot Noir 2023
                                        Sonoma County, California Pinot Noir
                                        • 92 James
                                          Suckling
                                        • 90 Jeb
                                          Dunnuck
                                        • 90 Wine
                                          Spectator
                                        3.6 Very Good (27)
                                          1
                                          Limit Reached
                                          Ships Mon, Apr 27
                                          Limit 0 per customer
                                          Sold in increments of 0
                                        • Last call - only 9 left!
                                          Eden Rift Estate Pinot Noir 2021
                                          Cienega Valley, Central Coast, California Pinot Noir
                                          • 93 Decanter
                                          • 92 Robert
                                            Parker
                                          • 92 Jeb
                                            Dunnuck
                                          • 91 Vinous
                                          4.8 Fantastic (36)
                                          • Boutique
                                          1
                                          Limit Reached
                                          Ships Mon, Apr 27
                                          Limit 0 per customer
                                          Sold in increments of 0
                                        • Willamette Valley Vineyards Whole Cluster Pinot Noir 2023
                                          Willamette Valley, Oregon Pinot Noir
                                          • 92 James
                                            Suckling
                                          • 91 Wine
                                            Enthusiast
                                          • 90 Jeb
                                            Dunnuck
                                          3.6 Very Good (121)
                                          • Green
                                          1
                                          Limit Reached
                                          Ships Mon, Apr 27
                                          Limit 0 per customer
                                          Sold in increments of 0
                                        • L'Aventure Optimus 2021
                                          Willow Creek District, Paso Robles, Central Coast, California Other Red Blends
                                          • 95 James
                                            Suckling
                                          • 95 Robert
                                            Parker
                                          • 93 Jeb
                                            Dunnuck
                                          • 93 Decanter
                                          • Green
                                          1
                                          Limit Reached
                                          Ships Mon, Apr 27
                                          Limit 0 per customer
                                          Sold in increments of 0
                                        • Masseto Tuscany 2022
                                          Tuscany, Italy Merlot
                                          • 98 Jeb
                                            Dunnuck
                                          • 98 Decanter
                                          • 97 James
                                            Suckling
                                          • 96 Wine
                                            Spectator
                                          • Collectible
                                          1
                                          Limit Reached
                                          Ships Mon, Apr 27
                                          Limit 0 per customer
                                          Sold in increments of 0
                                        • Last call - only 1 left!
                                          St. Supery Cabernet Sauvignon 2019
                                          Napa Valley, California Cabernet Sauvignon
                                          • 95 Tasting
                                            Panel
                                          • 94 Wine
                                            Enthusiast
                                          • 92 James
                                            Suckling
                                          • 90 Jeb
                                            Dunnuck
                                          3.8 Very Good (38)
                                          • Green
                                          1
                                          Limit Reached
                                          Ships Mon, Apr 27
                                          Limit 0 per customer
                                          Sold in increments of 0
                                        Sorry, we couldn't find any matches.

                                        Browse by Category

                                        Red White Sparkling Rosé Spirits Gifts
                                        Show More Viewing 100 of 172

                                        3 Scores 90+