Critics' Picks 239 Items

List Page Learn About Content Graphic

You're no longer following this brand

You'll no longer receive alerts for new arrivals and brand updates

Critics' Picks, null
All Filters
Gift Type
Gift Type
    Occasion
    Occasion
      Variety
      Variety
        Price
        Price
        Price $0 $300+
        Rating
        Rating
        Professional Rating Unrated 100 points
        Customer Rating Unrated 5.0 fantastic
        Ships Anytime
        Availability
        Shipping availability and out of stock options
        Size & Type
        Fine Wine
        ABV
        ABV
        ABV 0% 18% +
        Reset
        Back to All Filters
        Filter & Sort
        239 Items
        Most Popular
        Search results for "" 239 Items
        • Last call - only 1 left!
          Dominus Estate 2021
          Yountville, Napa Valley, California Bordeaux Red Blends
          • 100 Jeb
            Dunnuck
          • 100 Decanter
          • 99 James
            Suckling
          • 98 Vinous
          • 96 Wine
            Spectator
          4.5 Fantastic (11)
          • Collectible
          1
          Limit Reached
          Ships Tomorrow
          Limit 1 per customer
          Sold in increments of 0
        • Billecart-Salmon Le Reserve (375ML half-bottle)
          Champagne, France Non-Vintage Sparkling Wine
          • 93 James
            Suckling
          • 91 Wine
            Spectator
          • 91 Robert
            Parker
          • 90 Jeb
            Dunnuck
          4.5 Fantastic (42)
          • Green
          1
          Limit Reached
          Ships Tomorrow
          Limit 0 per customer
          Sold in increments of 0
        • Marchesi Antinori Pian Delle Vigne Brunello di Montalcino 2020
          Montalcino, Tuscany, Italy Sangiovese
          • 94 Wine
            Spectator
          • 94 James
            Suckling
          • 93 Vinous
          • 92 Jeb
            Dunnuck
            1
            Limit Reached
            Ships Tomorrow
            Limit 0 per customer
            Sold in increments of 0
          • Last call - only 7 left!
            Vina Cobos Bramare Lujan de Cuyo Malbec 2022
            Mendoza, Argentina Malbec
            • 96 Tasting
              Panel
            • 95 James
              Suckling
            • 94 Jeb
              Dunnuck
            • 92 Robert
              Parker
            • 90 Wine
              Spectator
            3.9 Very Good (8)
              1
              Limit Reached
              Ships Tomorrow
              Limit 0 per customer
              Sold in increments of 0
            • Flowers Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir 2023
              Sonoma Coast, Sonoma County, California Pinot Noir
              • 94 Jeb
                Dunnuck
              • 93 Decanter
              • 93 James
                Suckling
              • 92 Vinous
              • 92 Wine
                Spectator
              • 91 Robert
                Parker
              3.8 Very Good (36)
                1
                Limit Reached
                Ships Tomorrow
                Limit 0 per customer
                Sold in increments of 0
              • Fess Parker Ashley's Chardonnay 2023
                Sta. Rita Hills, Santa Barbara, Central Coast, California Chardonnay
                • 92 James
                  Suckling
                • 92 Decanter
                • 92 Jeb
                  Dunnuck
                • 92 Vinous
                • 90 Wine
                  Spectator
                  1
                  Limit Reached
                  Ships Tomorrow
                  Limit 0 per customer
                  Sold in increments of 0
                • Concha y Toro Amelia Chardonnay 2022
                  Limari Valley, Chile Chardonnay
                  • 97 James
                    Suckling
                  • 97 Vinous
                  • 93 Wine
                    Spectator
                  • 93 Decanter
                  • 91 Wine
                    Enthusiast
                    1
                    Limit Reached
                    Ships Tomorrow
                    Limit 0 per customer
                    Sold in increments of 0
                  • Last call - only 8 left!
                    Faust Cabernet Sauvignon 2022
                    Napa Valley, California Cabernet Sauvignon
                    • 92 James
                      Suckling
                    • 90 Robert
                      Parker
                    • 90 Jeb
                      Dunnuck
                    4.2 Very Good (52)
                      1
                      Limit Reached
                      Ships Tomorrow
                      Limit 0 per customer
                      Sold in increments of 0
                    • Bodegas Vatan Tinta de Toro 2021
                      Toro, Spain Tempranillo
                      • 96 Vinous
                      • 94 Jeb
                        Dunnuck
                      • 92 Wine
                        Spectator
                      • 92 James
                        Suckling
                      3.6 Very Good (25)
                        1
                        Limit Reached
                        Ships Tomorrow
                        Limit 0 per customer
                        Sold in increments of 0
                      • Ridge Paso Robles Zinfandel 2023
                        Paso Robles, Central Coast, California Zinfandel
                        • 94 Wine
                          Spectator
                        • 94 Jeb
                          Dunnuck
                        • 93 Vinous
                        • 92 Robert
                          Parker
                        • 92 James
                          Suckling
                        3.6 Very Good (9)
                        • Green
                        1
                        Limit Reached
                        Ships Tomorrow
                        Limit 0 per customer
                        Sold in increments of 0
                      • Beaulieu Vineyard Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon 2021
                        Napa Valley, California Cabernet Sauvignon
                        • 94 James
                          Suckling
                        • 92 Wine
                          Enthusiast
                        • 91 Wine
                          Spectator
                        • 90 Jeb
                          Dunnuck
                        4.0 Very Good (32)
                        • Green
                        1
                        Limit Reached
                        Ships Tomorrow
                        Limit 0 per customer
                        Sold in increments of 0
                      • Poggio Antico Brunello di Montalcino Riserva 2017
                        Montalcino, Tuscany, Italy Sangiovese
                        • 95 Wine
                          Enthusiast
                        • 94 James
                          Suckling
                        • 94 Wilfred
                          Wong
                        • 93 Wine
                          Spectator
                        • 92 Robert
                          Parker
                        5.0 Fantastic (24)
                        • Collectible
                        • Boutique
                        1
                        Limit Reached
                        Ships Tomorrow
                        Limit 0 per customer
                        Sold in increments of 0
                      • Spring Valley Uriah 2019
                        Walla Walla Valley, Columbia Valley, Washington Bordeaux Red Blends
                        • 94 Robert
                          Parker
                        • 92 Wine
                          Spectator
                        • 92 James
                          Suckling
                        • 91 Wine
                          Enthusiast
                        • 91 Wine
                          & Spirits
                        • Boutique
                        1
                        Limit Reached
                        Ships Tomorrow
                        Limit 0 per customer
                        Sold in increments of 0
                      • Carpineto Farnito Cabernet Sauvignon 2018
                        Tuscany, Italy Cabernet Sauvignon
                        • 92 Wine
                          Spectator
                        • 91 Wine
                          Enthusiast
                        • 91 James
                          Suckling
                        • 90 Vinous
                        3.3 Good (10)
                          1
                          Limit Reached
                          Ships Tomorrow
                          Limit 0 per customer
                          Sold in increments of 0
                        • Last call - only 9 left!
                          Spring Valley Uriah 2017
                          Walla Walla Valley, Columbia Valley, Washington Bordeaux Red Blends
                          • 92 Wine
                            Spectator
                          • 92 Wine
                            Enthusiast
                          • 92 James
                            Suckling
                          • 91 Robert
                            Parker
                          • 91 Jeb
                            Dunnuck
                            1
                            Limit Reached
                            Ships Tomorrow
                            Limit 0 per customer
                            Sold in increments of 0
                          • Louis Roederer Collection 246 (375ML half-bottle)
                            Champagne, France Non-Vintage Sparkling Wine
                            • 93 James
                              Suckling
                            • 93 Wine
                              Spectator
                            • 93 Jeb
                              Dunnuck
                            • Green
                            1
                            Limit Reached
                            Ships Tomorrow
                            Limit 0 per customer
                            Sold in increments of 0
                          • Carpineto Vino Nobile di Montepulciano Riserva 2019
                            Montepulciano, Tuscany, Italy Other Red Blends
                            • 91 Wine
                              Spectator
                            • 90 Wine
                              Enthusiast
                            • 90 James
                              Suckling
                            3.7 Very Good (11)
                              1
                              Limit Reached
                              Ships Tomorrow
                              Limit 0 per customer
                              Sold in increments of 0
                            • Patz & Hall Sonoma Coast Chardonnay 2022
                              Sonoma Coast, Sonoma County, California Chardonnay
                              • 93 Wine
                                Spectator
                              • 92 James
                                Suckling
                              • 90 Jeb
                                Dunnuck
                              3.6 Very Good (29)
                                1
                                Limit Reached
                                Ships Tomorrow
                                Limit 0 per customer
                                Sold in increments of 0
                              • Marchesi Antinori Badia a Passignano Chianti Classico Gran Selezione 2022
                                Chianti Classico, Chianti, Tuscany, Italy Sangiovese
                                • 95 James
                                  Suckling
                                • 94 Vinous
                                • 94 Robert
                                  Parker
                                • 93 Wine
                                  Spectator
                                • 92 Decanter
                                  1
                                  Limit Reached
                                  Ships Tomorrow
                                  Limit 0 per customer
                                  Sold in increments of 0
                                • Last call - only 6 left!
                                  Chateau de Nalys Saintes Pierres de Nalys Chateauneuf-du-Pape 2019
                                  Chateauneuf-du-Pape, Rhone, France Rhone Red Blends
                                  • 93 Jeb
                                    Dunnuck
                                  • 92 Robert
                                    Parker
                                  • 91 James
                                    Suckling
                                  • Green
                                  1
                                  Limit Reached
                                  Ships Tomorrow
                                  Limit 0 per customer
                                  Sold in increments of 0
                                • Ayala Brut Majeur
                                  Champagne, France Non-Vintage Sparkling Wine
                                  • 94 James
                                    Suckling
                                  • 90 Jeb
                                    Dunnuck
                                  • 90 Wine
                                    Spectator
                                  • 90 Robert
                                    Parker
                                  3.5 Very Good (111)
                                    1
                                    Limit Reached
                                    Ships Tomorrow
                                    Limit 0 per customer
                                    Sold in increments of 0
                                  • Fanti Brunello di Montalcino 2020
                                    Montalcino, Tuscany, Italy Sangiovese
                                    • 94 James
                                      Suckling
                                    • 93 Wine
                                      Spectator
                                    • 92 Robert
                                      Parker
                                    • 92 Vinous
                                      1
                                      Limit Reached
                                      Ships Tomorrow
                                      Limit 0 per customer
                                      Sold in increments of 0
                                    • Last call - only 1 left!
                                      Tenuta Luce Toscana 2021
                                      Tuscany, Italy Tuscan Blends
                                      • 96 James
                                        Suckling
                                      • 95 Wine
                                        Spectator
                                      • 93 Robert
                                        Parker
                                      • 93 Vinous
                                      4.7 Fantastic (5)
                                        1
                                        Limit Reached
                                        Ships Tomorrow
                                        Limit 0 per customer
                                        Sold in increments of 0
                                      • Ramos Pinto 20 Year Tawny Quinta do Bom Retiro
                                        Douro, Portugal Port
                                        • 95 James
                                          Suckling
                                        • 94 Decanter
                                        • 93 Wine
                                          Spectator
                                        • 93 Robert
                                          Parker
                                        • 92 Wine
                                          Enthusiast
                                        • 92 Wilfred
                                          Wong
                                        • 91 Wine
                                          & Spirits
                                        4.2 Very Good (36)
                                          1
                                          Limit Reached
                                          Ships Tomorrow
                                          Limit 0 per customer
                                          Sold in increments of 0
                                        • Louis Roederer Blanc de Blancs 2017
                                          Champagne, France Vintage Sparkling Wine
                                          • 96 Wine
                                            Enthusiast
                                          • 95 James
                                            Suckling
                                          • 95 Jeb
                                            Dunnuck
                                          • 93 Wine
                                            Spectator
                                          • 92 Robert
                                            Parker
                                          • Green
                                          1
                                          Limit Reached
                                          Ships Tomorrow
                                          Limit 0 per customer
                                          Sold in increments of 0
                                        Sorry, we couldn't find any matches.

                                        Browse by Category

                                        Red White Sparkling Rosé Spirits Gifts
                                        Show More Viewing 225 of 239

                                        3 Scores 90+