Red Wines    Cabernet Sauvignon    Napa Valley    California   
Wine.com - Buy wines, wine clubs, gift baskets and more
My Rating (circle) :
Date Printed: 11/28/2014
Scarecrow Cabernet Sauvignon 2005
Scarecrow Cabernet Sauvignon 2005
(search item no. 114122)
collectible wine
boutique wine
older vintages

The Wine Advocate rating: 96 points
Wine Spectator rating: 96 points
PRICE ON 11/28/2014: $449.99

ratings pedigree (past vintages):
2011 The Wine Advocate rating: 93 points
2011 International Wine Cellar rating: 92 points
2011 Wine Spectator rating: 91 points
2010 The Wine Advocate rating: 98 points
2010 Wine Spectator rating: 94 points
2009 International Wine Cellar rating: 95 points
2009 Wine Spectator rating: 94 points
2009 The Wine Advocate rating: 92 points
2008 James Suckling rating: 99 points
2008 Wine Spectator rating: 96 points
2008 International Wine Cellar rating: 94 points
2008 The Wine Advocate rating: 93 points
2007 The Wine Advocate rating: 100 points
2007 Wine Spectator rating: 97 points
2007 International Wine Cellar rating: 97 points
2003 The Wine Advocate rating: 98 points

Winemaker's Notes:

A mix of intensely ripe cherry, blackberry and dark plum aromas blend with floral notes of lavender and rosewater and the sweet spice of milk chocolate, cinnamon bark and warm vanilla custard. As the wine opens up in the glass, faint hints of caramel and honey emerge. The palate entry is dominated by dark berry and chocolate flavors, then broadens to include vanilla, fruit and forest floor notes. Texturally, the wine feels like heavy satin in the mouth, with only the finest-grained tannins adding structure to the finish.
My Notes:

Additional wines from Scarecrow:

About Scarecrow:

THE SCARECROW STORY

The Scarecrow story begins in a patch of earth with a fabled past. The J.J. Cohn Estate, where Scarecrow grapes are born, borders what was once the legendary vineyard of Inglenook winemaker Gustave Niebaum, whose plantings blanketed more than 1,000 acres of the Napa Valley at the close of the 19th century.

John Daniel Jr. took the helm at Inglenook in 1939, determined to restore the label to pre-Prohibition standing and produce world-class Bordeaux-style wines. In 1945, Daniel convinced his neighbor, J.J. Cohn, to plant eighty acres of Cabernet vines on the 180-acre parcel Cohn had purchased a few years prior. The property served as a summer retreat for Cohn's wife and their family. He had no ambitions to become a winemaker himself, but Daniel promised to buy his grapes, so Cohn planted vines. The rest, as they say, is history.

J.J. Cohn fruit figured prominently in Inglenook's superlative Cabernet Sauvignons of the post-war era, and has more recently gone into wines of such renown as Opus One, Niebaum-Coppola, Duckhorn, Insignia and Etude.

J.J. Cohn Estate grapes are highly sought-after in part because Cohn bucked the trend, begun in the mid- 1960s, of replacing vines planted on St. George rootstock with the supposedly superior AxR#I hybrid. Over time, vines grafted onto this new stock proved highly vulnerable to phylloxera. But by then, virtually all of the old St. George vines in Napa had been destroyed. Only the original 1945 J.J. Cohn vines survived. These highly prized "Old Men" continue to produce uncommonly rich fruit—the hallmark of Scarecrow wine.

But the Scarecrow story doesn’t end there. This is more than a tale of enchanted ground and the exceptional wine that flows out of it. The Scarecrow story is a story, too, of an extraordinary family legacy. Joseph Judson Cohn was born in Harlem in 1895 to Russian immigrants. Cohn spent his childhood in dire poverty and never learned to prefer the taste of fresh bread over stale—even after he’d found great success in Hollywood.

A move west in the 1920s launched Cohn’s studio career. Highly resourceful and extremely capable, Cohn began as a bookkeeper, distinguished himself early and rose quickly through the ranks to become Chief of Production at MGM. His unofficial credo, "Nothing is impossible," became the motto of his MGM staff. They knew him as a man who simply refused to take "No" for an answer.